Artem ZbandutLogistics entrepreneur, founder of Black Sea Forwarding

Warehousing

Artem Zbandut: scam warehouses and how online sellers vet a 3PL before shipping stock

Published 11-minute readBy Artem Zbandut

Artem Zbandut, who founded the Odesa logistics firm Black Sea Forwarding, sets out how a scam fulfilment house takes an online seller's stock or upfront fees, and why sellers tend to notice weeks later. The checks rely on public UK sources: HMRC's register of approved fulfilment businesses, Companies House, the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, and the reporting routes through your bank and Report Fraud.

Artem Zbandut: scam warehouses and how online sellers vet a 3PL before shipping stock

Artem Zbandut: how a scam fulfilment house wins a seller's trust

For a small online retailer, handing storage to a fulfilment house frees up space, staff and evenings spent packing. The provider books stock in, keeps it on racking, picks orders and sends replenishment to the marketplace's warehouses. From the moment the lorry is unloaded, the seller sees their stock only through the provider's own spreadsheets.

Fraudsters exploit exactly that. As long as parcels go out, nobody chases. Problems appear when the stock sheet shows units that never ship, or when the seller asks for everything back and is told part of it has already gone to someone else.

Artem Zbandut set up Black Sea Forwarding in Odesa in 2019, moving grain and steel structures by multimodal container routes, and in 2022 he rebuilt the company's supply chains onto road and rail routes through Ukraine's western borders. He looks at fulfilment the way a freight forwarder looks at any handover: who signs for the goods, what paper proves it and what the owner can check unaided.

Between goods-in and the marketplace warehouse, the seller sees stock only through the provider's own sheets.

Four scam patterns in UK fulfilment

Vanishing stock: months of normal service, then part of the inventory is sold off or moved while the stock sheet keeps the old figures. The gap shows when a replenishment run to the marketplace comes up short.

The phantom warehouse: a slick website, photos of pallet racking and a trading estate address, yet another business occupies the unit or it stands empty. The goods are collected from a cross-dock and the trail goes cold.

Upfront storage fees: a generous discount for paying a season or a whole year in advance, often bundled with prep and labelling. Once the money lands, the goods-in date keeps slipping and the account manager stops replying.

Short counts and swaps at goods-in: the receipt shows fewer units than were sent, damage nobody saw, or part of the stock replaced with lookalikes. The scheme counts on the seller not being there when the cartons were opened.

Each scam relies on the seller seeing the stock only through the provider's eyes, which is why every check below aims to give you an independent view.

Artem Zbandut: scam patterns in UK fulfilment and the check for each
PatternWhat you seeCheck
Vanishing stockstock sheet disagrees with the marketplace accountmonthly visit and weekly reconciliation
Phantom warehouseonly photos from the websiteCompanies House, address and live video
Upfront storage feesdiscount for a year in advancemonthly invoicing in arrears
Short counts and swapsfewer units or fresh damage at goods-inpacking list, weights, packing video
Subcontracted storagestock collected from another sitewritten consent clause
Changed bank detailsemail about a new accountring the number in the contract

HMRC's fulfilment house register: Artem Zbandut's first check

One part of this market in the UK has its own register of approved fulfilment businesses. Under the Fulfilment House Due Diligence Scheme, a business needs HMRC approval if it stores goods that were imported from outside the UK, are owned by or stored for someone established outside the UK, and are offered for sale without having been sold in the UK before.

Trading as a fulfilment business before HMRC approves the application is a criminal offence, and GOV.UK warns of a £10,000 penalty and a criminal conviction. HMRC publishes a list of registered businesses, last updated on 10 September 2026, so that overseas sellers can check whether the business storing their goods is registered.

A UK-established seller's own stock may sit outside the scheme, so absence from the list proves nothing by itself. Artem Zbandut still suggests looking: a provider that courts overseas brands yet is missing from HMRC's list is either wrong about its obligations or not what it claims to be.

Companies House: who is behind the trading name

Next comes the company that will sign the contract. Companies House data on GOV.UK is free: registered office, incorporation date, current and former directors, previous names and any insolvency history, with free alerts when something changes.

Companies House has required identity checks for new directors and people with significant control since 18 November 2025; existing ones were given a 12-month transition. A fulfilment firm incorporated weeks before it started asking for a year's fees upfront deserves a closer look, and so does a trading name that leads to a company in an unrelated line of business.

Then compare three addresses: the contract, the Companies House record and the place where the loading bays actually are. Artem Zbandut recommends a live video call from goods-in showing the entrance, the unit number and the racking. A provider that can show only its own website photos has failed the first test.

Records a registered fulfilment house must keep

Approved businesses carry duties that help a careful seller. GOV.UK says they must keep, for six years, records of their overseas customers and their VAT numbers, the type and quantity of goods in the warehouse and the import entry numbers, and must check customers' VAT numbers. Penalties run to £500 for each record-keeping breach and from £500 to £3,000 for failing to check VAT numbers.

Even where the scheme does not cover you, those duties show what a serious operator can produce: a stock record by product and quantity, tied to inbound paperwork. Ask for a sample monthly stock report before signing. Artem Zbandut treats a provider that cannot show one as a provider that does not really know what sits on its racking.

Ask too how stock is counted between deliveries. A provider that runs regular cycle counts and can send the results by product line is far harder to use for a scam than one that reconciles only when a customer complains.

UK sources in Artem Zbandut's scam checks: FHDDS, Companies House and statute
SourceWhat it gives youWhat to look for
HMRC fulfilment house listregistered businesses storing overseas sellers' goodsprovider listed if it serves overseas brands
FHDDS guidancewho must apply, offence, £10,000 penaltyapproval before trading
FHDDS record rulesstock type and quantity kept for six yearssample stock report
Companies Houseoffice, directors, history, alertsrecent incorporation, unrelated business
Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, s.13reasonable care and skillcare standards in the contract
Same Act, s.15reasonable charge if price not fixedcomplete rate card
Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977, s.2conversion claim for loss by a baileeevidence of what was delivered

Artem Zbandut on the contract and the duty of reasonable care

In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, section 13 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 implies into a business service contract a term that the supplier will carry out the service with reasonable care and skill. Contracts covered by the consumer services chapter of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 fall outside it, so business-to-business fulfilment contracts stay within its reach.

Section 15 adds that where the price is not fixed by the contract, the customer pays a reasonable charge, and what is reasonable is a question of fact. That is a good reason to have every fee, from goods-in to returns handling, written into the rate card, so that a surprise charge cannot be passed off as reasonable later.

Write the rest down as well: the address of every site that may hold your stock, no subcontracting to another warehouse without written consent, a unit count at goods-in, the right to inspect stock, monthly stock reports and compensation based on the value of the goods. Artem Zbandut reads any clause capping compensation at one month's storage fee as a warning.

Goods-in checks against a scam swap or short count

Disputes start at goods-in. Artem Zbandut advises preparing your side of the evidence before the lorry leaves: a packing list for every carton with SKUs and quantities, carton weights, photos of labels and a short packing video with carton numbers in shot. A discrepancy report can then be checked against paperwork.

Agree how goods-in works: unit count or carton count, who pays, how quickly the goods-in report arrives and how discrepancies are logged with photographs. A count kept only in the provider's internal system, never shared with the seller, protects no one.

Use your inspection right every month, in person or by video. A spot check of a few lines catches a swap well before customers start leaving reviews about the wrong item. A provider that will not let the owner see their own stock has answered the question for you.

Evidence a seller prepares before stock reaches the fulfilment house.

Zbandut on upfront fees, stock held back and mandate fraud

A year's storage paid in advance at a discount is the oldest hook in this trade. Once it is paid, the seller has lost the one lever that keeps a provider responsive. Pay monthly in arrears against a stock report, in pounds, to the bank account of the company named in the contract.

Some operators hold stock back by inventing fees. A charge that appears nowhere in the agreed rate card is weak ground for refusing to release goods, and Artem Zbandut suggests a written demand for release that cites the contract and sets a firm collection date.

Mandate fraud targets the same invoices. Report Fraud describes letters and emails, apparently from a familiar supplier, asking for payment to new bank details, often from lookalike addresses and with fake invoices. It advises checking the request through the supplier's known contacts, making a small test payment and letting only designated staff change payee details.

Paying a fulfilment house: scam signals and safer habits, per Artem Zbandut
SignalWhy it mattersSafer habit
Discount for a year upfrontall risk sits with the sellermonthly invoicing in arrears
Payment to an individualno link to the contracted companycompany account only
New bank details by emailmandate fraud patternring the known number, test payment
Fees missing from the rate cardpretext to hold stock backevery fee agreed in writing
Refusal to show stocknothing to compare with reportsinspection right in the contract

Artem Zbandut on lost or sold stock: conversion and the police

If goods are lost or destroyed because the provider breached its duty as bailee, section 2 of the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 allows a claim in conversion. Civil claims of this kind need the usual evidence: contract, goods-in reports, stock reports and payment records.

When the provider has sold or removed the stock itself, it is a matter for the police. Since 4 December 2025, fraud in England, Wales and Northern Ireland is reported to Report Fraud, which replaced Action Fraud, at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040. HMRC advises people in Scotland to contact the police on 101.

Call your bank straight away if a payment went to the wrong account. Artem Zbandut suggests keeping every email and chat with the provider in its original form, with dates and sender addresses: that record shows later who promised what.

Order of steps when a fulfilment house stops replying and still holds the seller's stock.

Spotting a scam pitch before any stock moves

Most of these schemes announce themselves in the sales conversation. Prices well below what established providers quote, a promise to book in any volume the same day, pressure to sign this week to keep a discount and reluctance to put anything in writing all point the same way. None of them proves fraud on its own, and together they justify slowing down.

Watch how the provider handles questions. A genuine operator explains its goods-in process, names the site where your stock will sit, sends a draft contract and a rate card without being chased, and agrees to a visit. A scam operation tends to answer with screenshots of reviews, testimonials from brands you cannot contact and a fresh reason why the visit has to wait.

Artem Zbandut suggests writing down every promise made on calls and asking for each one to appear in the contract. A commitment that disappears between the call and the draft was never meant to be kept.

Artem Zbandut: a scam checklist for UK sellers before sending stock

Before signing: HMRC's fulfilment house list where relevant, a Companies House record that matches the contract, an address that matches the loading bays, a live video from goods-in and a sample stock report. In the contract: unit counts at goods-in, inspection rights, no subcontracting without consent, every fee in the rate card and compensation based on the value of the goods.

Send a small first consignment and test everything on it: how fast the goods-in report arrives, whether the counts match, whether you can see the stock, whether stock reports turn up without chasing. Artem Zbandut sees a trial consignment as the cheapest way to learn how a provider behaves before peak-season stock sits on its racking.

Pay monthly in arrears, in pounds, to the contracted company's account, and confirm any new bank details by phone using the number in the contract. A provider that refuses those terms has told you everything worth knowing.

Questions answered

How does Artem Zbandut spot a scam fulfilment house?
By paperwork and access. A genuine provider matches its Companies House record, appears on HMRC's fulfilment house list if it serves overseas sellers, counts units at goods-in, issues a goods-in report for every delivery, lets the owner inspect stock and invoices monthly to its own business account.
Why does Artem Zbandut see a year's storage paid upfront as a scam risk?
It hands all the risk to the seller before any stock has been stored. Paying monthly in arrears against a stock report limits the loss to one month if the provider disappears.
Does a UK fulfilment house need HMRC approval?
It does if it stores goods imported from outside the UK for someone established overseas, offered for sale and not sold in the UK before. Trading before approval is a criminal offence.
What standard of service can I expect from a fulfilment house?
In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, section 13 of the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982 implies a term that a business supplier carries out the service with reasonable care and skill.
Can I check who runs a fulfilment company for free?
Yes. Companies House data on GOV.UK is free and shows the registered office, incorporation date, directors past and present, previous names and insolvency history.
Where do I report a fulfilment scam in the UK?
Call your bank first if money has gone, then report to Report Fraud at reportfraud.police.uk or on 0300 123 2040. In Scotland, contact the police on 101.

Further reading

All posts