Artem ZbandutLogistics entrepreneur, founder of Black Sea Forwarding

Customs and storage

Artem Zbandut: reviews of customs brokers and storage warehouses, how to check them

Published 11 min readBy Artem Zbandut

Artem Zbandut looks at how to read reviews of customs brokers, freight forwarders and storage warehouses, and which claims in them you can check yourself. This is written for US importers and exporters who shortlist a broker from star ratings and trade directories: who must hold a license, what a broker is required to tell you about payments, how the FMC handles ocean intermediaries, what happens to cargo after fifteen days, and what the FTC now says about fake reviews.

Artem Zbandut: reviews of customs brokers and storage warehouses, how to check them

Artem Zbandut: reviews of customs brokers and where they run out

A broker's profile usually shows a star average and a handful of short comments: fast clearance, slow replies, great team. An importer choosing who will file an entry worth tens of thousands of dollars needs different answers. Is this firm allowed to do the work, who is liable if the duty goes unpaid, and what happens if the cargo sits too long? Reviews rarely touch any of that.

Artem Zbandut founded Black Sea Forwarding in Odesa in 2019. The company handles multimodal container shipping of grain and steel structures, and his plans center on a digital marketplace for chartering freight transport in Eastern Europe that automates paperwork and customs clearance. In this piece he separates what a review can tell you from what only a public record can.

The starting point is simple. Customs brokers and ocean intermediaries operate under licenses issued by federal agencies, and their core duties to clients are written into regulations. Those can be checked without asking the firm. A review is a useful prompt for questions and a weak piece of evidence.

Why customs reviews read differently from restaurant reviews

A diner rates a meal they just ate. A broker's client sees only the outcome: the cargo was released, or it was held. Exams, holds and requests for more information come from CBP, and the frustration they cause often lands on the broker who delivered the news.

CBP also reminds importers that even when they use a broker, the importer of record is ultimately responsible for the accuracy of what was filed and for all duties, taxes and fees. A glowing review describes speed. It says nothing about whether the classification and value were right, and an error there can surface months later.

Artem Zbandut suggests pulling facts out of each review: the date, the port, the type of goods and what actually went wrong. Impressions about friendliness matter too, but you can only test those in your own dealings with the firm.

The way a firm answers criticism is worth a look as well. A short, polite reply that offers to discuss the case privately is normal for a business that handles other people's commercial data. A reply that argues in public, names the client or posts their shipment details shows how that firm treats information.

Artem Zbandut: reviews of a broker versus public records, what each one shows
QuestionWhat a review saysWhat a record shows
Is the firm licenseda customer's opinionCBP permitted broker directory
Who owes the dutynothingimporter of record stays liable
How payments workit was easywritten notice under 19 CFR 111.29
Who signed with youthe forwarder handled itdirect power of attorney
Is the forwarder licensedfive starsFMC list of licensed and bonded OTIs
Is the bond in placenot visible$50,000 to $150,000 by type
Why storage was chargedangry comment15-day general order rule

Licensed or not: the first check Artem Zbandut runs

Under 19 CFR 111.2, a person must hold a broker license to transact customs business as a broker. There are narrow exceptions, such as an importer filing solely on its own account, or an employee acting only for the licensed broker who employs them. A friendly expediter who promises to clear your goods without a license is outside those exceptions.

CBP's customs broker page links to a Find a Permitted Broker directory, and it points to section 641 of the Tariff Act of 1930 and Part 111 of the CBP Regulations as the basis for licensing. CBP also notes that licensed brokers are not CBP employees, so anyone implying that they work for customs while selling you clearance services is overstating their position.

Match the legal name on the power of attorney you are asked to sign with the directory. Review platforms often attach ratings to a trade name, and two firms with similar names can sit a few blocks apart in the same port city.

Artem Zbandut on reviews and money: the notice every broker must give

Under 19 CFR 111.29, a broker must pay duty and other government charges on or before the due date. Money a client sends after the due date has to be passed on within 5 working days, and the broker must account in writing for client funds it holds within 60 calendar days.

The same section requires a written notice to every client. It says that if you are the importer of record, paying the broker does not relieve you of liability for customs charges if the broker fails to pay them, and that you can pay those charges by a separate check made out to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The notice belongs on or with the power of attorney and must be repeated each year to active clients.

Artem Zbandut treats this notice as a quick integrity test. If the power of attorney arrives without it, ask why. A review praising how easy the broker made payments says nothing about whether your duty actually reached CBP.

He also asks each broker how the client will see that a payment reached CBP and how often statements are sent. The 60-day rule for accounting statements gives you a fair yardstick: a firm that cannot say where your money is after two months has a bookkeeping problem, whatever its rating says.

Duty paid through a broker: if it never reaches CBP, the importer of record is still on the hook.

Power of attorney and forwarders: who you actually hired

Many importers meet their broker through a freight forwarder, and reviews often praise the forwarder for handling customs too. Under 19 CFR 111.36, the broker must execute the customs power of attorney directly with the importer of record, never through a forwarder or other third party.

Any referral fee arrangement between broker and forwarder cannot stop you from talking to the broker directly. If the broker is hired by someone who is not the actual importer, the rule also requires the broker to send the importer a copy of the bill or the entry, unless the importer waived that in writing.

So when a forwarder's reviews say customs is included, ask for the name of the licensed broker and a direct contact there. A forwarder that will not share it is asking you to trust a chain of people you cannot check.

Artem Zbandut keeps one more document from this stage: the forwarder's written confirmation of which licensed broker will file your entries. If the broker changes mid-season, the reviews you read no longer describe the firm doing your work.

What a broker owes you in information

Under 19 CFR 111.39, a broker must not withhold information about the customs business it handles for you and must not knowingly give you false information. It has to use due diligence in the advice it gives, including advice on paying duty, and must tell you promptly if it learns that you made an error or are out of compliance.

The same section bars a broker from suggesting any illegal plan to evade duty. That makes reviews boasting that a broker saved the reviewer a fortune on duty worth a second look. Savings can be lawful, through correct classification or a trade program, and they can also be a warning sign.

Artem Zbandut points out the flip side. A complaint that a broker kept asking for documents or flagged a problem with the invoice may describe a firm doing exactly what the regulation requires.

What US rules require of brokers and ocean intermediaries, as Artem Zbandut compares them with reviews
RequirementCustoms brokerOcean intermediary
Who licensesCBP under Part 111Federal Maritime Commission
Legal basissection 641, Tariff Act of 193046 CFR Part 515
Financial securityset by CBP rules$50,000 to $150,000 bond
Public listsFind a Permitted Brokerlicensed, status changes, non-compliant
Duty to clientno withheld or false informationcovered by bond claims
Payment ruleduty paid on time, notice to clientset by contract and tariff

Artem Zbandut: reviews of ocean forwarders and NVOCCs

Ocean freight adds another layer. Under 46 CFR 515.3, no person in the United States may advertise, hold itself out or act as an ocean transportation intermediary without a license from the Federal Maritime Commission. That covers ocean freight forwarders and non-vessel-operating common carriers.

Each must also post financial security. Under 46 CFR 515.21 the amount is $50,000 for an ocean freight forwarder, $75,000 for a licensed NVOCC and $150,000 for a registered foreign NVOCC. A bond does not make a firm honest, though it gives claimants something to pursue.

The FMC's licensing page carries a list of licensed and bonded intermediaries, a list of license status changes and a list of NVOCCs that are out of compliance. Artem Zbandut checks all three before reading what customers say, because a revoked license makes last year's five-star reviews irrelevant.

When a review praises an NVOCC for a low rate, check which kind of NVOCC it is. A licensed one based in the United States and a registered foreign one carry different bonds, and a claim against them would run through different channels.

Reviews of warehouses and the 15-day general order clock

Some of the angriest warehouse reviews are about storage charges. Under 19 CFR 4.37, cargo landed without a release permit can stay at the place of unlading until the fifteenth calendar day. After that it goes to a general order bonded warehouse, and transport and storage are at the consignee's risk and expense.

Before taking such a complaint at face value, ask whether the entry was filed in time. Many of those charges trace back to paperwork that arrived late, and a review rarely mentions that part of the story.

Artem Zbandut advises agreeing with the broker in writing on when the entry will be filed relative to arrival and who pays if the deadline is missed. That one clause prevents more disputes than any amount of reading reviews.

Warehouse reviews also mix up different kinds of facility. A carrier's terminal, a container freight station and a general order warehouse can sit side by side, and a complaint about one is often posted under the name of another. Confirm which facility your cargo is assigned to before you weigh what people say about it.

Fake reviews: what the FTC rule bans

On August 14, 2024 the FTC announced a final rule banning fake reviews, including ones generated by AI, paying for reviews that express a set sentiment, undisclosed reviews by employees and suppressing negative reviews through threats. Brokers and warehouses are covered like any other business.

The rule has teeth. On December 22, 2025 the FTC sent warning letters to 10 companies about possible violations and noted civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation.

The FTC's own advice for consumers applies well here: read reviews critically on sites you trust and search the company name together with the words scam, review or complaint. Watch for bursts of ratings within a few days, identical phrasing across different authors and profiles that only ever praise the same set of firms.

Artem Zbandut adds one more habit: sort reviews by newest and read the last ten in full. A firm whose recent comments mention unanswered emails or unexplained charges has changed, whatever its long-run average says.

Signs of fake reviews about customs brokers, from Artem Zbandut's breakdown
SignWhat it looks likeWhat to do
Burst of ratingsdozens of reviews in a few dayscheck dates and profiles
Same phrasingnear-identical text from different peoplecompare wording
No detailno port, goods or entry typeask the broker directly
Wrong firmpraise for a similar trade namematch the legal name
Wave of negativessame complaint on one daycheck license status
Duty savings boastbig savings with no reason giventreat as a warning

Artem Zbandut: reviews, red flags and a checking order

Start with the broker's name in CBP's permitted broker directory and the legal name on the power of attorney. Confirm the payment notice is attached. For ocean freight, check the FMC lists for the forwarder or NVOCC. Then agree in writing on entry timing and on who pays storage if it slips.

Artem Zbandut reads reviews last, once the records check out. At that stage they help with questions no register answers: how fast the team replies, how it handles an exam, whether payment receipts arrive without chasing.

If money has gone to someone posing as a broker, contact your bank first, then report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or by phone at 1-877-FTC-HELP. Keep the power of attorney, invoices, payment records and screenshots of the listing.

Six checks that take about an hour and need no paid services.

Questions and answers

How does Artem Zbandut suggest reading reviews of a customs broker?
Last, after checking the CBP permitted broker directory, the payment notice on the power of attorney and, for ocean freight, the FMC lists. By then reviews help with service questions and no longer decide the choice.
Why does Artem Zbandut check licenses before reading reviews?
Because a license can be revoked while old five-star reviews stay online. Under 19 CFR 111.2 a license is required to act as a customs broker, and the FMC publishes license status changes for ocean intermediaries.
Does paying my broker settle my duty with CBP?
No. Under 19 CFR 111.29 brokers must tell clients in writing that paying the broker does not relieve the importer of record of liability if the broker fails to pay CBP.
Can a freight forwarder sign the customs power of attorney for me?
No. Under 19 CFR 111.36 the broker must execute the power of attorney directly with the importer of record, never through a forwarder or other third party.
How long can cargo sit before it goes to general order?
Under 19 CFR 4.37 cargo without a release permit can stay at the place of unlading until the fifteenth calendar day, then moves to a general order warehouse at the consignee's risk and expense.
Are fake reviews of a broker illegal?
The FTC rule announced in August 2024 bans fake reviews, paid reviews with a set sentiment, undisclosed employee reviews and suppressing negative reviews by threats.

More from the blog

All articles