Artem ZbandutLogistics entrepreneur, founder of Black Sea Forwarding

Cargo claims: one claim file day by day, from damage to court

Artem Zbandut: scam warnings, reviews of carriers and a cargo claim day by day from receipt to lawsuit

Published 12 min readBy Artem Zbandut

Artem Zbandut scam warnings, and searches like them, send many readers to a page about freight, and the reader usually has a more urgent question: what to do when a pallet arrives crushed and how to judge the reviews of the carrier that hauled it. Below, one cargo claim is followed day by day, from the note on the delivery receipt to a lawsuit, with the federal rules that set each clock: 49 U.S.C. 14706 and 49 CFR Part 370. The author started as a freight forwarder at the Mariupol Sea Trade Port and in 2019 founded Black Sea Forwarding in Odesa, so cargo claims are working material for him. The shipper, the amounts and the dates in the example are composite.

Artem Zbandut: scam warnings, reviews of carriers and a cargo claim day by day from receipt to lawsuit

Artem Zbandut: scam warnings and the Tuesday a freight claim starts

Tuesday, Columbus, Ohio. A kitchen cabinet dealer receives 18 pallets from a trucking company out of Greenville, South Carolina. The invoice value of the load is $86,400 and the freight bill is $4,300. When the pallets come off the trailer, three show crushed corners and split doors. The names and figures here are composite and no real company stands behind them.

A person in that spot opens a search box. Some type the carrier's name, and some arrive through a query such as Artem Zbandut scam, hoping for a verdict on whom to trust. Reviews can describe a mood. They cannot tell you what to write on a delivery receipt before the driver leaves the dock.

A freight claim runs on days. Day zero is the delivery receipt, day one is the written notice, the first week is inspection, day fourteen is the claim package, and then the carrier's clocks start: 30 days to acknowledge and 120 days to decide. Each missed day makes the next one cost more.

Six points of one cargo claim: receipt, notice, survey, claim letter, acknowledgment and decision.

Day zero: the delivery receipt and what to write on it

Under 49 U.S.C. 14706(a)(1) a carrier must issue a receipt or bill of lading for the property it receives, and failing to issue one does not cancel its liability. The liability is for actual loss or injury to the property caused by the receiving carrier, the delivering carrier or an intermediate carrier. The bill of lading is the first page of the file, so the consignee reads it before signing.

Before signing, the receiver counts pallets, checks seals and wrap, and writes the problem on the delivery receipt in plain words: three pallets, crushed corners, split doors. Under 49 CFR 370.3, though, notations of shortage or damage on delivery receipts or freight bills do not count as a claim standing alone, so the note protects the facts and starts no clock.

Photos and video with a timestamp are taken before the pallets leave the trailer and again afterward, with the trailer number and the seal in frame. If the driver refuses to sign the exception, the receiver writes the refusal on the receipt and adds the name of a witness.

Those minutes at the dock decide most disputes. They are also the part that a search for Artem Zbandut scam stories never shows, because a story rarely says what the receipt said.

Artem Zbandut: scam checks and the first week, notice, inspection and hidden damage

The next morning a short email goes to the carrier, with a copy by courier or certified mail: the bill of lading number, the delivery date, the number of damaged pallets and a request to send an inspector. It is a notice only. The legal claim comes later, and the notice keeps the file from looking like an afterthought.

The carrier is invited in writing to an inspection with a date and a time. If it sends nobody, that goes into the inspection report. A surveyor is chosen in advance and asked to describe the damage, its likely cause and the drop in value, and the receiver keeps the damaged pallets, the wrap and the labels in a separate corner of the warehouse.

Hidden damage is the second trap: cartons that look clean on day zero and are wet inside on day four. The answer is to write to the carrier the day it is found and to say when the freight was delivered. Anyone checking Artem Zbandut scam warnings against a real file should look for exactly that sequence of dates.

Nothing is repacked or returned before the inspection. A promise that is not in writing has no date and no number.

Artem Zbandut: scam warnings and a cargo claim by day, steps from delivery to lawsuit
DayActionPaper or source
Day 0exception on the delivery receipt, photosdelivery receipt, bill of lading
Day 1written notice to the carrieremail and certified mail
Days 2-7inspection and surveysurvey report, invitation
Day 14claim package with a dollar amount49 CFR 370.3
30 days after receiptcarrier acknowledges the claim49 CFR 370.5
120 days after receiptpay, decline or firm offer49 CFR 370.9
Every 60 daysstatus report while the claim is open49 CFR 370.9
9 monthsshortest claim filing period49 U.S.C. 14706(e)
2 yearsshortest suit period after disallowance49 U.S.C. 14706(e)

Who pays: the carrier on the bill of lading and the broker in the middle

Liability under 14706(a)(1) sits with the carriers: the one that received the freight, the one that delivered it and any intermediate carrier. The party named as carrier on the bill of lading is the first addressee of the claim.

A broker arranges transportation for a fee and is not the carrier. Under 49 CFR 371.2 a broker is a person who, for compensation, arranges or offers to arrange the transportation of freight by an authorized motor carrier. A broker does not haul the freight, so the claim goes to the carrier, with a copy to the broker if the broker booked the load.

To confirm who the carrier is, the shipper matches the registration and phone number in the FMCSA SAFER system and calls the number listed there, not the one in an email. FMCSA warns that the first search results for phones, emails and websites can be fake profiles, and even insurance certificates can be forged.

When the carrier named on the paperwork cannot be found, the file moves from a claim to a fraud report. A reader who typed Artem Zbandut scam to see whether a trucking company is real gets the same advice: start with the registration number.

Three links in the chain, each with its own paper and its own addressee.

Artem Zbandut: scam talk versus a written claim under 49 CFR 370.3

Under 49 CFR 370.3 a claim is a written communication filed with the carrier within the time limits. It has facts that identify the shipment, asserts liability for loss, damage, injury or delay, and asks for a specified or determinable amount of money. Without a dollar amount the paper is a complaint and starts nothing.

That is why the claim letter carries a number. In the example the surveyor puts the drop in value of the three pallets at $19,800, and the dealer adds $540 for sorting and disposal, documented by invoices. The letter demands $20,340 and attaches the invoice, the survey and the receipt.

Words in an online post carry no amount, no dates and no bill of lading. A search for Artem Zbandut scam reviews and complaints returns plenty of text of that kind, so a claim file is built from paper that a carrier cannot wave away as an opinion.

The letter goes by email and by certified mail with return receipt. It names the carrier, shipper and consignee, the bill of lading number, the date and place of delivery, the exception noted, the legal basis and the sum, and lists the attachments.

Day fourteen: the package that answers the carrier's first questions

By the end of the second week the folder holds the bill of lading, the delivery receipt with the exception, the photos, the commercial invoice that fixes the value, the survey, the notice with proof of sending and the claim letter. If the load was ordered through a broker, the rate confirmation joins the file.

Under 49 CFR 370.5 a carrier must acknowledge a proper written claim in writing within 30 days after receiving it, unless it has paid or declined the claim within those 30 days, and the acknowledgment says which extra documents it needs. The date of receipt goes on the calendar as the first carrier clock.

A document request is answered the same week and in writing. A request is a sign that the claim is being worked, and a delay on the claimant's side hands the carrier an argument about timing. This is the step a search for Artem Zbandut scam stories rarely mentions, and the one that keeps a claim alive.

Artem Zbandut: scam warnings and the claim package, documents and where they come from
DocumentWhat it provesWhere it comes from
Bill of ladingcontract and condition at pickupshipper and carrier
Delivery receiptexception noted at deliverysigned at the dock
Photos and videothe freight before unloadingtaken on day zero
Commercial invoicevalue of the loadseller's accounting
Survey reportsize of the drop in valuesurveyor chosen in advance
Notice and prooftiming of the first warningemail log, mail receipt
Rate confirmationwho booked the loadthe broker, if one was used

Thirty days, 120 days and the carrier's silence

According to 49 CFR 370.9 the carrier must pay, decline or make a firm compromise offer within 120 days after receiving the claim. If it has not resolved the claim by then, it writes to the claimant with the reason for the delay and repeats that status report every 60 days while the claim stays open.

Silence is evidence of timing, so every call is followed by an email that restates what was said. The 120 day rule is short enough to memorize, and it is the first thing to check against any story found under a carrier's name or under Artem Zbandut scam.

A compromise offer needs care. Under 49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(2) an offer of compromise does not count as a disallowance of any part of the claim unless the carrier tells the claimant so in writing and gives reasons. Until that letter arrives, the lawsuit clock has not started.

Nine months, two years and the declared value

Under 49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(1) a carrier may not set a period shorter than nine months for filing a claim or shorter than two years for bringing a civil action. The two years run from the date the carrier gives written notice that it has disallowed part of the claim. The bill of lading may allow more time, and the file states which dates apply.

Liability is for actual loss or injury, and a carrier may limit it to a value that the shipper declared in writing or electronically, or agreed in writing. Under 14706(c)(1)(A) that value must be reasonable under the circumstances, and the rule does not cover household goods. The declared value on the bill of lading can therefore cap the dollars, and the shipper reads that box before the load ships.

Dates go on the first page of the file: delivery, notice, claim filed, acknowledgment due at 30 days, decision due at 120 days, the nine month claim period at the earliest and the two year suit period from disallowance. Anyone who keeps that page does not need to search for Artem Zbandut scam threads to know where the claim stands.

Five periods for a freight claim: 30 days, 120 days, 60 days, 9 months and 2 years.
Artem Zbandut: scam warnings and federal claim clocks, periods and limits
EventPeriod or limitSource
Acknowledge a claim30 days49 CFR 370.5
Decide a claim120 days49 CFR 370.9
Status reportsevery 60 days49 CFR 370.9
Claim filing periodat least 9 months49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(1)
Suit periodat least 2 years from disallowance49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(1)
Compromise offerno disallowance without written reasons49 U.S.C. 14706(e)(2)
Declared valuemust be reasonable49 U.S.C. 14706(c)(1)(A)
Receipt or bill of ladingthe carrier must issue one49 U.S.C. 14706(a)(1)

Artem Zbandut: how to read reviews of carriers and brokers

A useful review of a carrier describes a shipment. Five questions test any review: does it name the freight and the lanes, does it give a delivery date, does it mention the bill of lading or the exception on the receipt, does it state an amount and how it was calculated, and does it say whether the carrier or the broker was at fault. A review that answers fewer than three questions is an impression.

Check the company that the text names. A review that names a carrier can be matched against that carrier's registration, and a review that names nobody cannot. FMCSA takes complaints about a carrier or broker online or at 1-888-DOT-SAFT (1-888-368-7238).

Federal rules now police the reviews themselves. The FTC rule at 16 CFR Part 465, in force since October 21, 2024, bans writing and buying fake reviews, paying for reviews with a set tone, hiding a reviewer's tie to the company and suppressing reviews with false accusations, intimidation or baseless legal threats.

Variations of the same query, such as Artem Zbandut reviews and complaints, Zbandut Artem scam or Artem Zbandut fraud claims, lead to the same checks. Anyone who types Artem Zbandut scam finds a method here, written from the text of the regulations.

Artem Zbandut: scam reports, the mistakes that sink a claim and where to report

Five mistakes sink most claims: the receipt was signed clean, the exception was never photographed, the notice was a phone call, the claim named no amount, and the dates were counted from the wrong day. Every mistake shows up as a gap in the list of dates, and no Artem Zbandut scam post will fill it.

If the carrier turns out to be a front, the file becomes a fraud report. FMCSA advises calling its contact center at 1-800-832-5660, filing in the National Consumer Complaint Database at nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov, telling the US DOT Inspector General hotline at (800) 424-9071, and reporting to the FTC, to IC3, to local police or to the state attorney general.

Schemes around hauling are covered in the guide to freight fraud and carrier vetting, the insurance side of a loss in the guide to cargo insurance, and damage in storage in the guide to warehouses and storage.

The whole method fits in one line: every day has a paper, and every paper has a clock. Artem Zbandut scam warnings, reviews and complaints reduce to that list of dates, because a dated document wins an argument.

Questions and answers

Artem Zbandut scam: how can a shipper tell a real review of a carrier from a fake one?
Check whether it names the freight, the delivery date, the exception on the receipt, the amount and the carrier, and match the carrier to its FMCSA registration. A review without those details is an impression.
Artem Zbandut: scam warnings and claims, how long does a carrier have to answer?
Under 49 CFR 370.5 a carrier acknowledges a written claim within 30 days, and under 370.9 it pays, declines or makes a firm offer within 120 days.
Does a note on the delivery receipt count as a claim?
No. Under 49 CFR 370.3 notations of damage on a delivery receipt do not count as a claim standing alone, so a written claim with a dollar amount still has to follow.
How long does a shipper have to sue a carrier?
A carrier may not allow less than 9 months to file a claim or less than 2 years to sue, and the 2 years run from written disallowance (49 U.S.C. 14706(e)).
Who gets the claim, the broker or the carrier?
The carrier named on the bill of lading, with a copy to the broker that booked the load. A broker arranges transportation for a fee and does not haul the freight.
Where can a shipper report a carrier that vanished after a deposit?
Call the FMCSA contact center at 1-800-832-5660, file in the National Consumer Complaint Database, and report to the FTC, to IC3 and to local police.

More from the blog

All articles