Cargo insurance
Artem Zbandut: fraud in cargo insurance, reviews of insurers and how to check a policy
Artem Zbandut, founder of the Odesa logistics company Black Sea Forwarding, explains how fraud in cargo insurance works on US shipments: a certificate no insurer ever issued, a seller with no state license, or a genuine policy whose exclusions swallow the very loss you are likely to have. The checks below rely on primary US sources: your state insurance department and the NAIC, the FMCSA rule on motor carrier cargo cover, and IC3 data on payment fraud. The last sections cover fake surveyors, the first day after damage and where to report fraud, including the FTC and IC3.
Artem Zbandut: fraud in cargo insurance surfaces on the day of the claim
Cargo gets insured so nobody has to think about it in transit. A shipper pays the premium, saves a PDF certificate next to the bill of lading and moves on. While the container is at sea or the trailer is on the interstate, nobody opens that file again, and that silence is what a fraudster counts on.
The trouble comes in two forms. In the first there was never any coverage: the document was made up, the premium went to a middleman, and no insurer knows the shipment exists. In the second the policy is real, yet its terms carve out the loss that is typical for this cargo, and the shipper learns about it from a denial letter.
Artem Zbandut started as a freight forwarder at the Mariupol Sea Trade Port and in 2019 founded Black Sea Forwarding in Odesa, which moves grain and steel structures on multimodal container routes. He reads a cargo policy the way he reads any other shipping document: who issued it, what it actually says, and how to verify it with a public source before the goods leave the dock.
Cargo insurance fraud: four schemes US shippers run into
The fake certificate. A document with a well-known insurer's logo, a policy number and a signature, paid for by wire to an intermediary. The insurer has never written the policy. Sometimes the number is real and belongs to someone else's account.
The unlicensed seller. A polished website, a price well under the market and a promise of claims paid within days. When the shipper checks, the company is not licensed by the state insurance department, or it is licensed for a different line of business.
The denial built on exclusions. The policy exists, but the wording excludes exactly the risk this cargo faces: packing, the nature of the goods, delay, a port where the box sits for weeks. The shipper never saw the full wording before paying.
The fake surveyor or adjuster. After a loss, someone claiming to work for the insurer calls, pushes for a quick inspection, asks for a fee or the original documents, and wants a signature on a report that blames the packing.
The short video below sums up Artem Zbandut's checklist in about thirty seconds: the fake shows up only after a loss, the insurer and the agent are checked with the state insurance department, the carrier's certificate is treated as the carrier's own cover, the wording and exclusions are read before payment, the surveyor is confirmed through the insurer, and the premium goes only to the account named in the contract.
| Scheme | What it looks like | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Fake certificate | known insurer's logo, wire to a middleman | insurer confirms the policy number |
| Unlicensed seller | low price, fast claim promises | license with the state insurance department |
| Wrong line of business | licensed, but not for cargo | licensed for the coverage you want |
| Hidden exclusions | denial citing the full wording | complete wording before paying |
| Hijacked payment | new wire instructions by email | call back on a known number |
| Fake surveyor | fee and signature demanded quickly | appointment confirmed by the insurer |
Artem Zbandut on checking an insurer with the state insurance department
Insurance in the United States is supervised state by state. The NAIC, founded in 1871, is governed by the chief insurance regulators of the 50 states, the District of Columbia and five US territories, and it describes the system it supports as state-based. For a shipper, the license that matters is the one issued by the insurance department of the state where the cover is sold.
NAIC guidance is blunt: to sell insurance in your state, both the company and the agent must be licensed. It suggests asking the state insurance department whether the company is licensed for the type of coverage you want, whether the agent legitimately represents that company, and what its complaint record looks like.
The NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search is a quick first look. The page itself tells users to confirm on the state insurance department's website that a company is licensed, and to contact the department where they live if the company cannot be found. Artem Zbandut treats a missing listing as a stop sign until the department answers.
Agents need the same check. A licensed agency can still have no appointment with the insurer it names, so Artem Zbandut asks the insurer directly whether the agent may bind cargo cover on its behalf. If the answer is no, the certificate that agent produced has no insurer behind it.
Fraud red flags from the NAIC, translated into freight terms
The NAIC lists warning signs of possible insurance fraud: pushy sales tactics, pressure to change coverage quickly, requests for large upfront deposits and offers that look too generous. In freight they sound like a quote far below the market, a demand to pay before the booking closes, and a full annual premium for an open cargo policy due by wire today.
The payment trail deserves its own check. A fake policy is one route; another is hijacking a real deal with new wire instructions sent from a lookalike email address. In its report for 2025 the FBI's IC3 counted 24,768 business email compromise complaints with losses of $3,046,598,558, second only to investment fraud.
Artem Zbandut's rule is simple. Bank details for a premium are confirmed by phone, using a number taken from the insurer's or the licensed agent's own records. A number printed in the email that carried the new instructions proves nothing.
Artem Zbandut on the carrier's certificate: whose cover is it?
Many shippers assume the trucking company's insurance protects their goods. Under an FMCSA rule effective March 21, 2011, most for-hire motor carriers of property and freight forwarders no longer have to maintain cargo insurance in prescribed minimum amounts or file evidence of it with FMCSA. The requirement stayed in place for household goods carriers and household goods freight forwarders.
So a general freight carrier may or may not have cargo coverage, and if it does, the limits, deductible and exclusions are set by its own policy. A certificate of insurance shows that a policy existed when the certificate was issued; it does not make the shipper a party to that policy.
Artem Zbandut asks for the certificate, then calls the insurer named on it to confirm the policy is active and covers the commodity being shipped. For valuable loads he prefers a shipper's own cargo policy, so recovery does not depend on someone else's paperwork.
Forwarders and brokers sometimes offer to add a shipment to their own cargo policy. That can work, provided the shipper knows who the assured is, whether the shipment was declared and who receives the claim payment. A quick yes from a dispatcher on the phone answers none of those questions.
| Party | What its insurance does | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| Household goods mover | cargo cover required by FMCSA | filing and certificate |
| General freight carrier | cargo cover set by its own policy | certificate, then a call to the insurer |
| Freight forwarder | cover depends on its contracts | who is the assured on the policy |
| Shipper's own policy | protects the shipper's interest | declarations and full wording |
| Agent or broker | sells cover for a licensed insurer | state license and appointment |
Artem Zbandut on reading a cargo policy: who signed it and what it covers
A genuine policy or certificate names the insurer, the assured, the goods, the transit from origin to destination, the limit, the deductible and the period. It is issued by the insurer or by an agent the insurer has appointed, and the legal name on it matches the name in the state insurance department's records.
Regular shippers often work under an open policy that covers many shipments on the same terms, with each shipment declared to the insurer. Declarations have deadlines. A shipment that was never declared may turn out to be uninsured, so the declaration receipt belongs in the file with the bill of lading.
Artem Zbandut asks for the complete wording, including every clause attached by reference, before the premium is paid. A one-page certificate that points to terms nobody has seen is half a contract, and the missing half is where denials usually come from.
Check the dates as well. A certificate issued after the goods left, or one whose period ends before the expected arrival, leaves part of the transit without cover.
Fraud or fine print: exclusions that sink claims and what to ask before you sign
Cargo wordings commonly exclude loss from insufficient packing, from the inherent nature of the goods, from delay and from ordinary wear. War and strikes are often covered only by separate clauses. None of this is fraud in itself, but a seller who hides these terms until after a loss is relying on the shipper not reading them.
The fix is to read the exclusions with the route in front of you: transshipment ports, storage time on the quay, temperature, open or enclosed equipment, the packing actually used. Where a risk matters, ask for it to be covered in writing and keep the endorsement.
Honesty runs both ways. Answer the underwriter's questions in writing and completely: packing method, container type, route, storage, value. Artem Zbandut keeps that email thread with the policy, because an accurate application removes the easiest argument for denying a claim.
Fraud by fake surveyors and adjusters: confirm the appointment with the insurer
Surveys are a normal part of cargo claims. The insurer appoints a surveyor or adjuster to record the damage and its cause, and it will confirm the name and firm if you ask. That makes the check easy: call the insurer on the number from its own website or from the state department's records.
A caller who appears out of nowhere, asks for a survey fee by wire or gift card, or pushes for a signature on a report that blames the packing fits the fraud pattern. If the insurer has no record of the appointment, end the conversation and tell the insurer about the call.
Artem Zbandut also keeps his own record of every inspection: photos and video of labels, seals and packing, the names of everyone present, and a written note on the report wherever its wording does not match what was seen.
Original documents deserve the same care. Hand them only to the party named in the policy, against a signed list, and keep copies of everything that leaves the office.
Damage on arrival: what Artem Zbandut does on the first day
Notify the insurer in writing as soon as the damage is found, using the method and deadline in the policy. Note the damage or shortage on the delivery receipt before signing it, and photograph the seals, marks and packing before anything is moved.
Keep the damaged goods until the surveyor has seen them, and put the carrier on written notice of loss or damage. These steps protect the insurer's right to recover from the carrier, and a policy may require them.
If the insurer replies that it has never issued the policy, ask for that answer in writing. It turns a dispute about coverage into a fraud report, and it is the first document a bank, a state insurance department or the police will ask to see.
Keep a simple claim file from the first hour: the policy and wording, the certificate or declaration, the bill of lading, the delivery receipt with exceptions, timestamped photos, letters to the carrier and every reply from the insurer. A complete file shortens the claim and makes any fraud report credible.
Artem Zbandut on reporting cargo insurance fraud in the US
Start with the state insurance department, the regulator that licenses insurers and agents and handles complaints about them. The NAIC itself points consumers to the department where they live whenever a company cannot be found.
The FTC takes fraud reports at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and by phone at 1-877-FTC-HELP (1-877-382-4357). Where the premium was diverted through a hijacked email or a spoofed invoice, file a complaint with the FBI's IC3 at ic3.gov as well.
Call your bank the moment you suspect a wire went to the wrong account, and keep every email, certificate and payment record. Artem Zbandut also writes to the genuine insurer whose name was used: insurers want forged certificates off the market, and their reply strengthens every other report.
Questions and answers
- How does Artem Zbandut spot fraud in a cargo insurance offer?
- He checks the insurer and the agent with the state insurance department, reads the full wording before paying, confirms payment details by phone on a known number, and asks the insurer to confirm any policy number he is given.
- Why does Artem Zbandut say a carrier's certificate is not fraud protection for the shipper?
- Since March 21, 2011, most for-hire carriers have no FMCSA duty to keep cargo insurance, and when they do, the limits and exclusions belong to the carrier's policy. Confirm the cover with the insurer named on the certificate.
- How do I check whether an insurance company is licensed?
- Contact the insurance department of your state or check its website. The NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search is a starting point, and the NAIC says to contact your department if a company cannot be found.
- What are the warning signs of insurance fraud according to the NAIC?
- Pushy sales tactics, pressure to change coverage quickly, requests for large upfront deposits and offers that look too generous.
- Should I pay a surveyor who calls after a cargo loss?
- Confirm the appointment with the insurer first, using a number from its own website. Insurers appoint surveyors themselves, and a stranger demanding a fee is a classic fraud pattern.
- Where can I report cargo insurance fraud in the United States?
- To your state insurance department, to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or 1-877-382-4357, and to the FBI's IC3 at ic3.gov if the payment was diverted by email.